From: Subject: CHICAGO SUN-TIMES :: Carol Marin :: Fight to help seniors runs into lobbyists' buzz saw Date: Wed, 15 Nov 2006 14:40:53 -0600 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/related; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_0000_01C708C4.0D992120"; type="text/html" X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V5.50.4133.2400 This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_0000_01C708C4.0D992120 Content-Type: text/html; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Location: http://www.suntimes.com/news/marin/136263,CST-EDT-carol15.article CHICAGO SUN-TIMES :: Carol Marin :: Fight to help = seniors runs into lobbyists' buzz saw

Traffic=20 =95 Weather:=20 "KERFUFFLE"
Search = =BB
=20
Site=20 = STNG
=95 Subscribe
=95 Reader=20 Rewards
=95 Customer = Service
=95 Email=20 newsletters

Home |=20 News=20 | Sports | Business=20 | Entertainment=20 | Classifieds = | Columnists=20 | Lifestyles=20 | Ebert |=20 Search | Archives | Blogs=20 | RSS=20 3D""=20 
3Dblogs3D"centerstage3D"yellow3Djobs3D"advertising3D"restaurant3D"roger3Dsudoku3Dcommentary =0A= =0A=
=0A= =0A=

Carol Marin
E-mail
News
Archive
Metro=20 & Tri-State
Nation
World
Blogs
Commentary
Editorials
Education<= /DIV>
Elections<= /DIV>
Lottery
Obituaries
Politics
Religion<= /A>
Weather
Special=20 Sections
George=20 Ryan Trial
Hired=20 Truck Scandal
<= !-- COLUMNISTS -->
Columnists
Monroe=20 Anderson
Tom=20 Bevan
Mark=20 Brown
Cathleen=20 Falsani
Ed=20 Feulner
Stella=20 Foster
Andrew=20 Greeley
Betsy=20 Hart
Jack=20 Higgins
Steve=20 Huntley
Jesse=20 Jackson
Mary=20 Laney
Jeremy=20 Levitt
Carol=20 Marin
Ralph=20 Martire
Tom=20 McNamee
Rich=20 Miller
Mary=20 Mitchell
Robert=20 Novak
John=20 O'Sullivan
Suzanne=20 Ontiveros
Other=20 Views
Debra=20 Pickett
QT
Cindy=20 Richards
Richard=20 Roeper
Dick=20 Simpson
Michael=20 Sneed
Neil=20 Steinberg
Mark=20 Steyn
Lynn=20 Sweet
Laura=20 Washington
George=20 Will
The=20 Fixer

 

=0A= =0A=

=0A= =0A=

Carol Marin :: = printer=20 friendly =BB   email=20 article =BB
=0A= =0A=

=0A= =0A=
VIDEO ::   = MORE=20 =BB

TOP STORIES = ::=20
Cop= s:=20 Success story a scam

BUSINESS<= /DIV>Sun-Ti= mes=20 Media Group appoints new CEO



Fight to help seniors runs = into=20 lobbyists' buzz saw

November 15, 2006
BY CAROL MARIN = Sun-Times=20 Columnist
State=20 Rep. Ruth Munson (R-Elgin) has stirred up quite a = little=20 hornet's nest. As I write this, Munson is down in = Springfield=20 fighting to override Gov. Blagojevich's veto of what = amounts=20 to a pretty small piece of legislation. But a phalanx = of new=20 lobbyists has descended on the Capitol, hired by an = industry=20 with deep pockets to defeat her. One of them is Bill = Filan,=20 cousin of the governor's budget = director.=20

This is the latest chapter in a David and Goliath = story=20 I've been telling you about for a while now.

For two years, Munson and a bipartisan band of = mostly=20 female legislators have been trying to help senior = citizens=20 who live in what we used to call mobile home parks. We = now=20 call them "manufactured home communities." The homes, = once=20 they are set on a foundation, are not mobile. And = neither are=20 their residents, many of whom are retirees who found = this=20 housing more affordable than a brick-and-mortar type = of=20 dwelling. About 300,000 people live in these = communities in=20 Illinois. If you put them all together, they would be = twice=20 the population of Rockford.

For years, most of these manufactured home parks = were Mom=20 and Pop operations. Now many of them have been gobbled = up by=20 huge corporations. The biggest of them all is the one=20 controlled by Chicago mega-zillionaire Sam Zell. His = nickname=20 is "The Grave Dancer" because Zell is a genius at = buying up=20 properties and turning them into gold mines. He is, = according=20 to Money Magazine, the "nation's biggest landlord."=20 Stockholders are the folks Zell worries about. = Residents of=20 these little communities don't appear to command as = much of=20 his interest. I don't know that firsthand, of course, = because=20 Zell hasn't ever wanted to talk to me.=20

But I have visited communities he owns. Last year I = watched=20 as an elderly couple in Elgin loaded up a moving van = and=20 abandoned their two bedroom home. They couldn't afford = the=20 rent any longer. Yes, they owned their house. But the = didn't=20 own the land underneath it. And when that rent began = to=20 skyrocket, they couldn't pay it anymore. They were = packing up=20 to live with a daughter out of state.

Little wonder that last March a couple of busloads = of=20 residents from all over the state, some in walkers, a = few in=20 wheelchairs, staged a demonstration in Springfield, = pleading=20 with lawmakers for a little relief.

Munson's bill provided homeowners a few modest = rights. A=20 longer lease agreement. A chance to appeal their rents = to an=20 independent arbiter. That arbitration, by the way, = wasn't even=20 binding. Last spring, after a lot of hard work, Munson = and her=20 colleagues in the House and Senate finally managed to = get a=20 watered-down version of her legislation passed.

What happened? Blagojevich vetoed it, arguing the = bill only=20 applied to publicly traded companies like Zell's, not = to=20 private companies. He was correct. Part of the = watering-down=20 that had taken place, thanks to industry lobbyists, = was to=20 make the legislation as limited as possible by tacking = a bunch=20 of amendments onto it. Blagojevich, with a stroke of = his=20 amendatory veto pen, could actually have restored the = full=20 power of the bill, making it applicable to all = manufactured=20 home communities, but he didn't.

Why? Have I mentioned big campaign contributions = yet? This=20 industry has handed out a lot of money to a lot of=20 politicians. Zell and his wife, Helen, for instance, = wrote=20 checks to Blagojevich in 2002 totalling $82,000. I = don't know=20 if the governor took that into account, but he might = have.

As of 3 p.m. Tuesday, Munson thought she had the = votes in=20 both houses to override the governor's veto. But it = was going=20 to be a fight. A national group called the = Manufactured=20 Housing Institute, a group that includes a number of=20 manufactured home companies including Zell's, sent a = letter to=20 legislators arguing that Munson's bill amounts to rent = control=20 and would create "irreparable harm" with "irreversible = consequences." For the record, Munson's bill does not = call for=20 rent control.

Attorney General Lisa Madigan is supporting the = Munson bill=20 and the attempt to override the governor's veto, = though=20 Madigan would prefer, said spokeswoman Cara Smith, = that the=20 original, even broader legislation be enacted.

At 4:05 p.m. Tuesday, my phone rang. It was Munson = from the=20 floor. "We just lost by two votes," she told me. "We = needed 71=20 yes votes; we got 69." Two people defected, she said, = "within=20 the last hour. Forty voted no, seven voted present."

Munson had one more chance to call it to a vote and = immediately went to work. At 4:58 she called back. She = and her=20 colleagues had managed to convert a few more votes. = They=20 overrode the governor's veto in the house with four = votes to=20 spare.=20

But don't think for a moment this fight is over. = Now the=20 measure heads to the Senate. But so do the lobbyists.

I'll keep you posted.